Corona Crisis: Life versus Freedom?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17808/des.58.1777Keywords:
Agamben, capitalism, class, freedom, struggle, surveillanceAbstract
Agamben says, "What becomes of human relations in a country that grows accustomed to living in this way for who one knows how long? What is a society that cleaves to no value other than that of survival?" The following paper is an examination of the dominant responses to the Corona Crisis, including a brief critical appraisal of Naomi Klein's "Disas- ter Capitalism." The paper argues that Agamben's biopolitical reading of COVID relies on a latent bourgeois-humanist worldview. The paper seeks to enumerate the ways in which Marxist postulates such as 'class struggle' and the 'internal contradiction of capitalism' can be a useful addition to the existing debates that try to address the concerns of an emergent sur- veillance society as social relations are inflected with, contestations and contradictions between liberty and security under a capitalist system. As we find ourselves in the middle of uncertain times, caught between infinite possibilities, this paper is an attempt at exploring the ways in which state of exception, biopolitics and class struggle can speak to each other to fill the theoretical gaps to study the situation of the COVID-19 pandemic.References
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life, (trans. D. Heller-Roazen). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1998.
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, "The Invention of an Epidemic," Quodlibet, February 26, 2020: https://bit.ly/3j65Uwl (Accessed Jun. 10, 2020). 2020a. AGAMBEN, Giorgio, "Normalising the State of Exception under the
COVID-19 Epidemic," Copyriot, March 28, 2020: https://bit.ly/
FR9pZq (Accessed Jun. 01, 2020). 2020b.
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, Means without an End: Notes on Politics, (trans. Cesare
Casarino and Vincenzo Binetti). Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press: Theory out of Bounds Series, Vol. 20, 2000.
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, "Clarifications", (trans. Adam Kotsko), An und für sich, 17 March 2020: https://bit.ly/2EpZCsH (Accessed Aug. 11, 2020). 2020c.
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, "Requiem for the Students," (trans. D. Alan Dean), Medium, 23 May 2020, https://bit.ly/2YmLIyz (Accessed May. 26, 2020). 2020d.
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, "Giorgio Agamben: Biosecurity and Politics", (trans. Julius Gavroche), Autonomies, May 13, 2020: https://bit.ly/2Yuou9P (Accessed Jun. 09, 2020). 2020e.
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, "A Question", (trans. Adam Kotsko), An und für sich. 15 April 2020: https://itself.blog/2020/04/15/giorgio-agamben-a-ques- tion/ (Accessed Feb. 12, 2021) 2020f.
AGAMBEN, Giorgio, "New Reflections", (trans. D Alan Dean) Medium, 23 April 2020, https://d-dean.medium.com/new-reflections-giorgio-ag- amben-c5534e192a5e (Accessed Feb. 12, 2021) 2020g.
Al Jazeera, "Israel Protest against Netanyahu's plan to annex West Bank," June 7, 2020: https://bit.ly/2YpRhMs (Accessed Jul. 17, 2020).
ARTHUR, C.J. "Labour. Marx's Concrete Universal," Australian Associa- tion for Philosophy, 29 August 2008, https://aap.tandfonline.com/doi/ abs/10.1080/00201747808601851?journalCode=sinq20 (Accessed Feb. 12, 2021).
ASHRAFI, Shah Tazrian. "How COVID-19 compounded caste discrimina- tion in Bangladesh," The Wire, September 11, 2020 https://thewire.in/ south-asia/bangladesh-caste-discrimination-dalits-covid-19 (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
BENJAMIN, Walter. "On the Concept of History", In: Theses on the Philoso- phy of History (1942), Accessed at https://www.sfu.ca/~andrewf/CON- CEPT2.html. (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
BENNET, Brian et al, 'Our Big War.' As Coronavirus Spreads, Trump Re- fashions Himself as a Wartime President, March 19, 2020.
Bloomberg. "Millions escaped caste discrimination. COVID-19 brought it back," August 21, 2020, https://indianexpress.com/article/in- dia/millions-escaped-caste-discrimination-covid-19-brought-it- back-6563993/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
BROPHY, Susan Dianne. Meaningless Authenticity: The Ethical Subject in Agamben's Early Works, Critical Horizons, 2015, 16:3, 246-263, DOI: 10.1179/1440991715Z.00000000050.
BUCHANAN, R.; FRANCHINI, D. "WhatsApp V. NSO Group: State Im- munity and Cyber Spying", Just Security, April 16, 2020 https://www. justsecurity.org/69684/whatsapp-v-nso-group-state-immunity-and- cyber-spying/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
CHHABRIA, Sheetal. "For Whom is the City a Border? From Colonial Space-Making to Postcolonial Governance in Mumbai", Social Science Research Council: Insights from Social Sciences, April 14, 2020: https:// bit.ly/34q28df (Accessed Aug. 14, 2020).
CORBETT, Jessica. "'We Know This Script': Naomi Klein Warns of 'Coro- navirus Capitalism' in New Video Detailing Battle Before Us", Com- mon Dreams, March 17, 2020. https://www.commondreams.org/ news/2020/03/17/we-know-script-naomi-klein-warns-coronavi- rus-capitalism-new-video-detailing-battle (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
DAVIS, Mike. "COVID-19: The Monster at the Door", Haymarket Books, March 12, 2020: https://bit.ly/2Qg0Aub (Accessed Aug. 17, 2020).
ET ONLINE. "Immunity certificates: The passport to a new life after Coro- navirus?", Economic Times, April 3, 2020: https://bit.ly/2Yurm6t (Ac- cessed Aug. 10, 2020).
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE. "Migrants Clash with Police in Surat, over 100 detained", The Indian Express, May 9, 2020. https://indianexpress. com/article/cities/ahmedabad/migrants-clash-with-police-in-surat- over-100-detained-6401883/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
FEMINISM IN INDIA. "ASHA workers protest: how primary health work- ers continue to be denied justice", Feminism in India, August 19, 2020 https://feminisminindia.com/2020/08/19/asha-workers-strike-de- mands-covid-19/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
FOUCAULT, Michel et al. The birth of biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1978-79, (trans. Graham Burchell, Arnold Davidson). UK: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.
FOUCAULT, Michel. Society must be Defended, March 17, 1976, (Ed. Mauro Bertani and Alessandro Fontana and trans. David Macey). New York: Picador, 2003.
GARCIA, Anibal. "Viralscapes. The bodies of others after COVID-19", Allegra Lab, March 31, 2020 https://allegralaboratory.net/viralscapes- the-bodies-of-others-after-covid-19/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021)
GUPTA, Aashish. "Tracking COVID-19 Mortality in India, Where Deaths Aren't Registered", The Wire, April 18, 2020: https://bit.ly/3gp3IP1 (Accessed Aug. 11, 2020).
HALL, Stuart. "The Problem of Ideology - Marxism without Guarantees", Journal of Communication Inquiry, 10 (2), June 1, 1986), pp. 28-44.
INDOREWALA, Hussain and WAGH, Shweta. "After the Pandemic, Will We Rethink How We Plan Our Cities?", The Wire, April 30, 2020 https://thewire.in/urban/city-planning-pandemic (Accessed Feb 13, 2021).
JOHN, Maya. "Remembering Marx in Lockdown Times - Beyond "Coro- na" Paradigm", Kafila, May 6, 2020: https://bit.ly/3laHxj5 (Accessed Jun. 10, 2020).
JOHNSTON, Adrian. Zizek's Ontology: A Transcendentalist Materialist Theo- ry of Subjectivity, Illinois: Northwestern University Press, 2008.
KAUNTIA, Nishant. "How Swiggy threatened to "suspend" protesting Del- hi workers after second pay cut in seven months", August 27, 2020, https://caravanmagazine.in/news/swiggy-pay-cut-delhi-worker-deliv- ery-protests-aigwu (Accessed Feb 13, 2021).
KLEIN, Naomi, et al. "Why a Climate Deal is the Best Hope for Peace", The New-Yorker, Nov. 18, 2015: https://bit.ly/3l8OVvf (Accessed Jul. 14, 2020).
KLEIN, Naomi. "How Big Tech Plans to Profit from Coronavirus Pan- demic", The Guardian, May 13, 2020 https://www.theguardian.com/ news/2020/may/13/naomi-klein-how-big-tech-plans-to-profit-from- coronavirus-pandemic (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
KOTHARI, Ashish et al. "Coronavirus and the crisis of the anthropocene", Econologist, March 27, 2020 https://theecologist.org/2020/mar/27/ coronavirus-and-crisis-anthropocene (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
KRISHNAN, Vidya. "The Callousness of India's COVID-19 Response", The Atlantic, March 27, 2020, https://www.theatlantic.com/international/ archive/2020/03/india-coronavirus-covid19-narendra-modi/608896/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
LENIN, Vladimir. "Left-Wing" Communism: an Infantile Disorder "Left- Wing" as pamphlet (June 1920). In: Collected Works, Volume 3, Mos- cow: Progress Publishers, 1964. pp. 17-118.
LIU, Andrew. "Chinese Virus, World Market", n=1 Magazine, March 23, 2020: https://bit.ly/32i4Ajo (Accessed Jul. 10, 2020).
MAO, Tse Tung. On Contradiction. In: Selected Readings from the Works of Mao Tse-Tung. First Indian Edition. Lucknow: Rahul Foundation, 2002.
MCFATE, Sean. "Venezuela shows how mercenaries have become a global security threat", Washington Post, May 14, 2020 https://www.washing- tonpost.com/opinions/2020/05/14/venezuela-shows-how-mercenar- ies-have-become-global-security-threat/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
MCGOWAN, Todd. "State of emergency? Bring it on!", The Philosophical Salon, LA Review of Books, April 30, 2020.
MILLS, Jen. "Hungary edging towards dictatorship under coronavi- rus with no end in sight", Metro, March 30, 2020. https://metro. co.uk/2020/03/30/hungarian-government-gets-sweeping-new-pow- ers-response-coronavirus-12480135/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
PETERS, M. A. "Philosophy and Pandemic in the Postdigital Era: Fou- cault, Agamben, Zizek", Postdigit Sci. Edu, 29 Apr. 2020: https://bit. ly/32gAgpb (Accessed Aug. 10, 2020).
PRIYA, Aditi, et al. "Coronavirus outbreak has fore grounded India's inequal- ities; country must re-examine social order when pandemic abates", Firstpost, April 1, 2020: https://bit.ly/2QgAyqr (Accessed Aug.10, 2020).
RIGAKOS, G. S. "Marxist Legal Theory: Security", Critical Legal Thinking, June 9, 2020: https://bit.ly/32jzCr1 (Accessed Jun. 23, 2020).
SAMPATH, G. "The 'shock doctrine' in India's response to COVID-19", The Hindu, June 15, 2020: https://bit.ly/3jahTt8 (Accessed Jun. 25, 2020). SAPKALE, Y. "Airtel is not alone. How everyone wants to breach your privacy and grab your personal data", Money Life, October 20, 2020, https://www.moneylife.in/article/airtel-is-not-alone-how-everyone- wants-to-breach-privacy-and-grab-your-personal-information/61869.
html (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
SEN, Shreya. "COVID-19 has pushed India's Already Suffering Tea Plan-
tation Workers into Deeper Crisis", The Wire, May 11, 2020 https:// thewire.in/labour/covid-19-lockdown-tea-workers-labour (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
SHARPE, Matthew. "Only Agamben can Save Us? Against the Messianic Turn Recently Adopted in Critical Theory", The Bible and Critical The- ory, 5 (3), 2009: 1-20.
SIRCAR, Sushovan. "Aadhaar Meets AI: Inside the Govt's Plan For a Health Data Empire", The Quint, July 24, 2019: https://bit.ly/3lj7zRt (Ac- cessed Jul. 26, 2020).
SOLIS, Marie. "Coronavirus is the Perfect Disaster for 'Disaster Capitalism'", Vice, March 16, 2020: https://bit.ly/2EnVdX3 (Accessed Jun. 20, 2020).
SOLTANI, Ashkan et al. "Contact-tracing apps are not a solution to the COVID-19 crisis", Brookings, 27 April 2020: https://brook.gs/32g4kS1 (Accessed Aug. 14, 2020).
SPAETH, Ryu. "America's Social Contract is Broken", The New Republic, June 1, 2020: https://bit.ly/34lZTrs (Accessed Jul. 16, 2020).
SRIVASTAVA, T. R. "I will never come back": Many Indian migrant workers refuse to return to cities post lockdown", Scroll, May 30, 2020: https:// bit.ly/3la5vuT (Accessed Jul. 10, 2020).
TACIK, Przemysław. "Provisional Marxist Theses on the Coronacrisis", Ex- ceptions, Apr. 9, 2020: https://bit.ly/34p94Ht (Accessed Jul. 14, 2020). TAKIEDDINE, Randa. "COVID-19 poses a huge challenge for Europe", Arab News, March 27, 2020: https://www.arabnews.com/node/1648481
(Accessed Feb. 15, 2021)
TEWARI, Avantika. "We are all Socialists now!", Medium, April, 2020
https://medium.com/@tewari.avantika/we-are-all-socialists-now-
f7c0b 2020a.
TEWARI, Avantika. "Coronavirus: What came before, what comes after?",
Medium, March 19, 2020. https://medium.com/@tewari.avantika/vi-
rus-and-the-techno-capitalist-boom-9e3ba83d2c2d 2020b.
LEFT VOICE. Trotskyist Fraction - Fourth International, "On the Front Line to Make the Capitalists Pay for the Pandemic and its Brutal Con- sequences", Left Voice, April 28, 2020: https://bit.ly/2YmNnUP (Ac-
cessed Jun. 02, 2020).
WALCOTT, D. Alexander. "How the Fourth Industrial Revolution can help
us beat COVID-19", World Economic Forum, May 7, 2020: https://bit.
ly/31ng7hX (Accessed Aug. 17, 2020).
WEHELIYE, A. G. Habeas Viscus: Racializing Assemblages, Biopolitics, and
Black Feminist Theories of the Human. Durham: Duke University Press,
WHITTAKER, Z. "A passwordless server run by spyware maker NSO sparks
contract-tracing privacy concerns", Tech Crunch, May 8, 2020 https:// mybe.online/2020/05/08/a-passwordless-server-run-by-nso-group- sparks-contact-tracing-privacy-concerns-techcrunch/ (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
WIELENGA, K.D. "'You can't go back': Migrant Workers told in Tamil Nadu", The Wire, May 9, 2020. https://thewire.in/labour/you-cant-go- back-migrant-workers-in-tamil-nadu (Accessed Feb. 13, 2021).
ZIZEK, Slavoj. "In American protests, victims of Trump's policies help the criminal erase the crime", RT, May 30, 2020: https://bit.ly/32l0ozg (Accessed Jul. 17, 2020).
ZIZEK, Slavoj. Trouble in Paradise: From the End of History to the End of Cap- italism. New York: Penguin Random House, 2015.
ZIZEK, Slavoj, For They Know Not What They Do: Enjoyment as a Political Factor. London: Verso, 1991.
ZIZEK, Slavoj. "Are We in a War, Do We Have an Enemy?", London Re- view of Books, 24(10), 2002: https://bit.ly/3j58BOT (Accessed Jul. 17, 2020).
ZIZEK, Slavoj. The Sublime Object of Ideology. New Delhi: Navayana, 2013.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Revista Direito, Estado e Sociedade
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The submission of articles for publication in the Law, State, and Society Journal(Revista Direito, Estado e Sociedade) implies the agreement of the authors with the following terms:
1. The author(s) authorize the publication of the text in an issue of the journal;
2. The author(s) assure that the submitted text is original and unpublished and that it is not under evaluation process in other journals;
3. The author(s) assume full responsibility for the opinions, ideas, and concepts sustained in the texts;
4. The author(s) grant the editors the right to make textual adjustments and adjustments to the journal's publication standards;
5. Total or partial reproduction of the articles is allowed, as long as the source is explicitly cited.
